Its best explained by this thread: https://mstdn.jp/@[email protected]/117645039420648634
TL:DR is that Google’s business side is threatening to revoke android licenses from phones that support GOS and is likely planning to lock the bootloaders on Pixel phones going forward. Important to note is that in GOS own words, the actual Google Android team is seemingly not down with it and has helped GOS work on things like Vanadium. As it stands it seems like Graphene is trying to take legal action against Google.
Google pixel phones worked in the first place because of the promise of great customisable software.
If Google fails to deliver on that single promise their whole hardware play is down the drains. And with FOSS alternatives becoming more and more popular, it seems like that is not far off. Surely more phone makers will make GOS compatible or unlockable phones if there is demand, either in the west or in China.
Yeah, they want to lock you into pixel so they have total control and only let you work within the sandbox they are willing to provide which funnels all purchases through the google play store and it’s cut (30% i’m guessing?)
By locking down apps and forcing people through their store they can limit or eliminate support for any kind of media they aren’t getting a cut from. Subscription revenue seems to be the only other goal of companies aside from advertising these days. Rent for life, own nothing. You work for their benefit or you don’t get to use modern technology.
I have been saying this day would come, and I intend to switch to Nura which is based on Alpine Linux instead of being AOSP based.
I have been thinking Google was going to attack AOSP systems for a very long time, and it’s coming true.
Never heard of this one. I’ll definitely look into it.
You may have heard of its old name, postmarketOS.
New Android features at this point are pretty much just “Gemini can now wipe your ass for you”
If it could actually do that, I might switch back to Android for it, I have a hairy ass so wiping is an arduous process.
Get a bidet, lol
I can’t install an electrical line for it in my rented bathroom.
yes many google haters around, so be it! many apple haters etc. We can’t all get along of course
so i guess its time for dual wielding?
Left hand Google BS phone. Right hand personal phone, maybe a Linux phone?
Anything but Apple. I used to be in their system, and i dont want to sell my kidneys just to get something fixed.
I am not doubting GOS claims, but what evidence is there about Google threatening to revoke licences to OEMs based on collaboration with GOS?
Something to think about: If GrapheneOS grows in usage their clientele are targets that Google wants. The framing by some users of Google harassing a tiny minority of consumers fails to understand that Google is a surveillance company. If all the high-value targets migrate entirely of Google’s platforms their leverage to secure governmental contracts weakens significantly.
I also think it’s the typical managerial class being disconnected entirely from the realities on the ground and within the organization’s working-class. Many of Google’s employees are against the position and direction the company’s moving towards. Google has a powerful monopoly and everything should be done to weaken it. Users should donate to GrapheneOS just in solidarity–take them to court and set precedent; what Google is doing should be illegal.
Yeah anyone under the illusion that google was ever a good company because of the free apps & services is really kidding themselves…
The linuxOS for phones is going to be a very welcome addition to the market.
If they kill graphene then I guess I’ll go back to iPhones. Fuck Google.
Gross. That walled garden is the same exact evil with less flexibility.
Meh. The way I see it, I can choose to use their walled garden services, or I can choose to use other services like I am now on GrapheneOS. I played with an iPhone recently after being on GrapheneOS for a number of years and the few things I want/need like a keepassXC client (which worked way better on iOS btw) and a basic web browser with adblock are there anyways.
Regarding less flexibility… I really don’t care. I don’t want to customize anything, I just want stuff to work.
Problem is Apple gadgets drill a blackhole in one’s pockets. :(
I was about to reply that iPhones aren’t THAT much more money. Then I went and checked the prices. Yuck.
In Canada iPhones and Pixels are about the same price with the exception that iPhones don’t go on sale. Trade-in values don’t matter to me since I hand my phones down to kids anyway.
Motorola is releasing its first Graphene phone in 2027. While it’ll be expensive, it probably shouldn’t take long for things to get cheaper—given that it’s Motorola.
Graphene seems pretty adamant that the security will be close to if not as good as it is on a pixel but I want to wait and see more before I get on board with that.
Ideally we should be pushing for Linux phones but I don’t see that becoming a thing for another 5+ years before Normie’s even really consider it. Things are different now though who knows, things are moving faster and more unpredictably.
Just in the past 5-6 years I feel like I’ve seen Linux move from this niche thing to something I could hand off to anyone and they would do okay-ish. So many small qols, and hardware issues just fixed. You used to just not be able to use 60% of GPUs, or had to use weird community drivers. I can’t express how impressive it is I don’t have to check proton db anymore. When I first got my steam deck it barely played anything besides 2d platformers on proton, and native Linux games. And before that you had to manually find a list of all the winefix things you had to do, and make your own wine prefix and none of it made sense and most of the time it didn’t work for some reason unknown to you. Things aren’t perfect still but its to the point shit just works.
Maybe I’m too hopeful I just don’t feel too confident piggy backing off google when we are essentially splitting off from their official version now. If I understood correctly graphene will have to reverse engineer updates which doesn’t sound promising. My only other hope is that we can force google to play nicely legally, they are easily a monopoly. I believe Tim Sweeny’s law suit against google was about that, sadly google seems to be responding by doubling down, and panicking that people don’t want to use the google playstore. Which is filled with malware, scams and endless slop.
There is a super massive Android ecosystem out there, and contrary to the computer situation, AOSP is a thing. It would take dramatically less efforts to fork AOSP than to bring the GNU/Linux phones up to speed.
Less effort on the OS, less effort from phone makes, less to no effort from the apps dev.
I don’t expect GOS to take on that alone, but there is a potential common interest from states seeking sovereinty, phone makers, other alternative Android distros.
I would bet more on that.
Hope you are doing right
just do an open-source Android phone for Graphene OS :D
And you fools thought Android was different than iOS lol!
Apple wanted to sell you devices you could not alter or easily repair since…they make money from devices Google wanted to sell you…no literally you…your data, your habits, your interactions - y’all bought that freedom bullshit and now you are such shock, much surprise
There is no ethical mainstream phone. If someone isn’t making money off of it they will either close the loopholes to ensure they do or shut those who circumvent their process down. There is no mobile charity.
Is it worth grabbing a new pixel right now and putting graphene on it before android is updated to fuck us?
I’m assuming theres less they can do if it’s already installed.
My current graphene pixel is starting to show its age but i was going to hold on a little longer before updating. A year if i can.
If you hit the lottery, you could get the new Motorola device next year.
2k for a phone is way outside my range money spent in a phone
worth considering at least. keep in mind the pixel 11 won’t have graphene support for a few weeks or so.
Doogee, RealME, Huawei, Fairphone and Blackview should all be explored as potential options for GOS.
All of which have dope RAM, amazing storage, kick-ass cameras and you can find cases for a majority of them. Pixel phones are okay in terms of future proof longevity but you’ll be able to keep a phone from the brands mentioned longer than most US brands.
That would be fantastic… but I somehow doubt GOS will condescend to that. They have been openly hostile to fairphone and Murena in particular for not being as hardened as their product. They seem to have a pattern of hostility to companies that would otherwise be working toward the same goals. Call it high standards, but I think it’s bad form.
I can’t say I doubt Google is above what GOS is accusing them of, but my past experience with GOS makes me read that whole thread with a grain of salt.
Per my understanding, Fairphone was not interested in working with them, and in security in general.
If those phones have the correct hardware (I think the TPM requreiment blocks most of them) I’d love to see them. My pixel 8 is awesome but so many phones have better features, I only have this one because I wanted GOS.
I don’t see why Google would care that much. The power of the default means 99.9% of phones are going to run whatever they came preinstalled with. So let that 0.01% exist so if regulators start making noises they can claim they’re open. Because they are. But attempting to shit on that % or being overtly hostile exposes them legally far more than just leaving things the way they are.
I don’t think Google cares about hobbyists and enthusiasts installing alternate operating systems.
Google cares very much about OEMs selling phones with non-GMS Android. SafetyNet first appeared not long after the Amazon Fire Phone, a phone preloaded with an Android fork and Amazon’ services and app store instead of Google’s. That failed on its own merits, but someone could have done it better.
Long time ago, Microsoft fell down on a PC maker proposing a dual-boot Windows/BeOS: either they were dropping Be, or they would no longer get OEM preferred price on Windows (a big difference with consumers direct selling price).
Windows was already at those 99.9% share.
Why? Because once you prove the alternative is viable, more hardware vendors will propose the alternative, and before you know, you have a real competition to deal with, and you fight for market share.
I don’t think they need to “care”, but keeping the door open a little, even to forks like Amazon / Baidu or whoever means they have some legal protection from claims the platform is a monopoly.
It’s in their interest for forks to exist and have a tiny market share of enthusiasts who were never going to be very profitable for Google anyway, but ensure there are enough usability issues those forks never take off with mainstream users.
I feel like it’s not a market share thing. If I had to take a guess, it’s pressure from governments. Governments really don’t like people having phones without Spyware on them. Especially “free” countries.
Because if there’s literally no alternative they can go rampant abusing customers. At the moment they have to keep some check on their abuse.
I mean, Google has also been trying to twist arms in education recently as well, I think their assumption now is “We are too big to regulate” and just dgaf if what they’re doing is illegal.
It sets a precedent that (to them) threatens that 99.9% share dropping.
Previously google forced manufacturers’ obedience and kept them from shipping devices with better OSes or “forks” by using their anti fragmentation licensing requirements. If Sony for eg wanted to sell one phone with a fork preloaded with lineageOS or something, they’d lose their android certification for all of their phones including those that didn’t ship with LOS (keeping them from shipping devices with google play store, gapps etc).
The European Commission ruled this anti-competitive in 2018 and now Motorola, a major manufacturer, is ‘threatening’ to sell a high end flagship with a much more secure and privacy respecting OS that makes google’s surveillance-malware infested flagship look like the steaming turd it is. So of course they’re going to throw threats and litigate to protect their profits.









