What are you are basically saying here, is that LLMs are functionally equivalent to intelligent systems but are not themselves intelligent. Most people will not find this satisfying because intelligence is defined in functional terms. Is something is flexible enough to solve a wide range of problems with human or above-human level accuracy then it is intelligent. Whether or not the system is a program, a human or an animal or some slime mold, or a bunch of statistics that system fits the functional criterion of an intelligent system.
That said, you don’t need to go so far as to ascribe nonfunctional mental characteristics to these systems. These are mental characteristics that cannot be described in functional terms, like eg pain or emotions; you can mimic pain or emotions (which is a functional behaviour) without actually feeling them (the intrinsic, nonfunctional part).
All I’m saying here is that LLMs fit the functional criterion of an intelligent system, which is the only criterion of intelligence we actually have.
What are you are basically saying here, is that LLMs are functionally equivalent to intelligent systems but are not themselves intelligent. Most people will not find this satisfying because intelligence is defined in functional terms. Is something is flexible enough to solve a wide range of problems with human or above-human level accuracy then it is intelligent. Whether or not the system is a program, a human or an animal or some slime mold, or a bunch of statistics that system fits the functional criterion of an intelligent system.
That said, you don’t need to go so far as to ascribe nonfunctional mental characteristics to these systems. These are mental characteristics that cannot be described in functional terms, like eg pain or emotions; you can mimic pain or emotions (which is a functional behaviour) without actually feeling them (the intrinsic, nonfunctional part).
All I’m saying here is that LLMs fit the functional criterion of an intelligent system, which is the only criterion of intelligence we actually have.
Does that make sense?